Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

  c) Watch another movie, paying its creator
     (possibly the same as in option a)
If the minority's of people do that, the shared culture is going to stay, but it will ignore the movie of options a) and b), and include that of option c).


The culture surrounds the media. Changing the media changes the culture and even within sub-cultures those sub-cultures themselves have niches. Sometimes cultures even rise out of a singular media.

You can't just replace "Vocaloid Music" (Miku, Rin, Luka) with "other synthetic vocals". It's "similar" but it is not "the same".

The cultures around Gumi and other Megpoids differs from that around Miku and other Vocaloids.


Yes, _we_ can. If some group, by the way they choose to distribute their product, indicates it doesn't want to be part of culture, culture can easily adapt to include other music.

When a billionaire buys a Van Gogh or it is sold to some museum far, far away, we look at other van Goghs. If all van Goghs were to get out of reach, some other painter would be brought to the spotlight and become _the_ painter.

(And edit on my grandfather post: s/minority/majority)


>by the way they choose to distribute their product, indicates it doesn't want to be part of culture,

That isn't how that works. Cultures get built around things - those things don't "choose" their culture. Even creators do not get to "choose" the culture their work belongs to. For example, Pepe the frog. Contrast the popular 4chan/pol/ usage of Pepe the frog with the viewpoints of the creator of Pepe the frog. Even the artist recently drawing Pepe taking a piss on Donald Trump won't stop or change the culture that has built up around the meme. Sometimes trying to not be part of a culture backfires. Ben Garrison learned that the hard way. The more he asked 4chan to stop - the harder 4chan pushed. Eventually it seems like he has given up fighting against it.

>When a billionaire buys a Van Gogh or it is sold to some museum far, far away, we look at other van Goghs. If all van Goghs were to get out of reach, some other painter would be brought to the spotlight and become _the_ painter.

I'm not sure what you mean by this. Not too big into art culture and don't really care if I have a cheap $30 copy or the $30mm original of the painting. If I wanted a van Gogh I'd get a van Gogh. Even if it weren't an original.


I can't edit any longer - but I think we're going to have to agree to disagree on this issue. I do not think you can change the focal point of a culture without changing the culture itself - as the focal point is what defines the culture.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: