Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

So why are doctors paid so much, it obviously has not improved service any?


Is there a strong correlation in any field between remuneration and quality of service? And even if there is, is there also evidence that changing the remuneration will have a proportional effect on the quality? Where in the s-curve/sigmoid/logistic function are we?

It seems plausible to me that simply increasing the supply of doctors and implementing air transport style safety systems would be much more beneficial than anything else we could do.


Unions for upper-middle-class professions aren't demonized as much as unions for those with less influence, so they get to control access to their profession.


Demand outstrips supply.

I think has not improved service any is also at least overly simplified. There's all sorts of treatments available now that were unheard of 10 years ago, never mind further into the past than that.


This. In Australia, half of the doctors do a 6 year undergraduate degree in medicine straight out of highschool while half do it as a 4 year postgraduate degree. Those that do the postgraduate degree don't need a PhD level GPA (they just need to do well in a test). Residency is not some sort of hazing ritual.

Everyone is much happier, and it fixes the supply vs demand problem.


You used to die at 50 from cancer or heart disease. Now you die at 80 from cancer or heart disease or medical error.

I think that's an improvement.


Indeed, one of the things that needs to be kept topmost in mind when reading statistics like this is that people are going to die of something, and as we reduce or all but eliminate other causes, something or things are going to shift to being the new "top causes".

ADDED: and because nowadays, no later than the end of WWII, the former somethings have be forestalled by medical interventions, as those increase, the number "killed" by the simple fact that healthcare workers are fallible humans is going to rise.

My father survived the immediate post-WWII period when he got a nasty bacterial pneumonia I think it was because civilians were then able to get the earliest form(s) of penicillin. Thanks to that medical intervention, which could have killed him (I've read that penicillin would never get approved by the FDA today because of its allergy potential), and others, now he'll die of Alzheimer's in his mid-'80s or his '90s, if nothing else gets him first.


It is but it doesn't have much to do with the income of the doctors.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: