Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is a very difficult area to draw a line on.

Your emotions can effect your actions and decisions like anything else. Are we to apply the same logic to how advertising made me feel a certain way leading to a purchase u wouldn't otherwise have made?

We are talking measures of degree here but it's a spectrum that is incredibly difficult to nail down.

What constitutes being of sound mind?



> Are we to apply the same logic to how advertising made me feel a certain way leading to a purchase u wouldn't otherwise have made?

I agree with your point about there being a line, but: YES!! ! Advertising has gone too far and is now squarely behind that line.

There is an all out war on our brains going on, and we are losing. Modern advertising and "engagement optimisation" is overwhelmingly insiduous and pernicious. People openly lecture about hacking faults in human psychology to make us buy more and pay higher prices, not to mention the new wave of shameless tracking and targeting. It does not move humanity closer to the stars.

Long live price and value based competition. Down with competition based on dirty psychological tricks.

It's a distraction from your main point, sorry for that. I couldn't let slip the opportunity for a call to arms against advertising.


Lumping all advertising into one box isn't just disingenuous, it's harmful.

Is the farmer advertising his grass-fed, hormone-free beef as a better alternative to what's currently standard grocery store garbage, doing harm?

There's a spectrum to everything, including tech.


Where can I get those ads?


> Are we to apply the same logic to how advertising made me feel a certain way leading to a purchase u wouldn't otherwise have made?

A thousand times yes!

People need some protections against bad actors hacking their brains. It wasn't a large problem in the past, but the bad actors are getting better and better at hacking.

It is still a continuous, so it will be hard to place lines. But it is something that must be done.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: