Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Because if Germany makes fewer nuclear plants, they'll make more coal plants.


Or more solar? Increase efficiency? Or use less?

False choice.


The situation in question is Merkel shutting down the 7 oldest German nuclear plants for 3 months. There will be no new clean sources of power deployed during those 3 months -- and unless there is a national campaign to reduce use starting right now in Germany, it will be mostly covered by coal.

During those 3 months, ~250 more will die to SO2 and NOx because of increased coal power production.


I'm disappointed that I was downvoted to 0 on this one. I didn't think I was overly argumentative and gave an honest response to the parent poster. I hate meta-comments, but they wouldn't be necessary if people wouldn't moderate based on personal agreement/disagreement.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: