Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't find it super obvious at all. I have to actively spend brain energy scrolling to find the first real result


Yep. The original top ad unit had a dark blue background, plus I think some sort of “sponsored” text that clearly delineated the ads. It has since become almost indistinguishable from organic results.

Edit: Used to look like this: http://photos1.blogger.com/blogger/3892/2343/1600/google_adw...


The appearance of the ads has gotten closer and closer to search results. The first time the ads moved above the results they did look different.


I don't use google, so I had a look for "new car" and didn't see any adverts.

Then realised I had to turn off my blocker.

Looks like

$('#tads').remove()

will remove the adverts?


No amount of adblocking will help with the fact that I got a top-hit to a car selling website when I searched for "new car".


What should be the top hit to the query "new car"? What was the desired goal?

It's a good chance someone wanting to find a "car selling" website might use that phrase, no?


Could be a lot of things, including wanting to buy a new car, yeah. But maybe I want to search for "new car smell", which is a thing. Maybe I want to read blogs or experiences people have buying new cars vs used.

Search as it is now is fundamentally at odds with us as our own agents. We're 30 years into the internet. I shouldn't just be presented with a magical search box that tries to figure out what I want and intermingles it with trash that makes them money and fosters a broken internet. Instead, I should get knobs, settings, configuration galore, include/exclude operators, filter lists, curated lists, sub-lists of internet sites, dynamic lists determined automatically by the search engine (only blogs, only forums, only search sites), etc. Who knows where search might be if we didn't have "magic" results from Google.

A good "taste" of what search might have been is if you look at Google's product or shopping search tab.


"new car smell"

- How to Make a Car Smell New Again - Auto Adviser

- How to Get That 'New Car Smell' in an Old Car - Car Cologne

- The Science of the New-Car Smell - caranddriver.com




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: