Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The story here is quite odd. I also ordered a CO2 meter and it changed my thoughts about my apartment. But in a former life I worked in fluid modeling.

> At baseline, the levels in my apartment were already dancing around 1,200 (ppm)...(marketing numbers)... I flung open a window... Two hours laterthe Aranet still hadn’t budged below 1,000 ppm

Something is very wrong here if your house/apartment is getting cold and a CO2 meter near a window is not dropping. Author should take it outside and check to see a number <500ppm (probably closer to 420). Device could be broken or poorly calibrated. It happens.

As for air flow in the apartment, this can often still be quite a mystery and weird to solve. My bedroom would constantly be above 800ppm, and above 600ppm with an open window. The solution? Opening a window on the other side of the apartment (need to pay very careful attention to paths that air can travel). A cracked window in my bedroom, a cracked window on the other side of the apartment, and boom, my bedroom is constantly near 400ppm (near ambient levels in my area).

But opening any other window in the apartment would not lead to this solution. Houses weren't designed with air flow in mind. Lots of hard corners can make it difficult to move air around (eddy currents are a pain). I do sleep better and there's probably some cognitive increase (I don't buy the 15-50%), but one of the larger benefits is the temperature is more stable (stable temperature is a good indication of good air flow btw). So I do encourage others to try this problem solving, but just want to note that the solutions are non-obvious. If you're having these issues, brute force the solution. You'll over think it (I did) but you're too clever by half[0]. You're working with a chaotic system and even the state of a door that doesn't seem in the flow path might affect the flow. If it isn't working, try dumb things and also use temperature as an indicator in addition to CO2. You can always use a fan too (draw air in on the opposite side of the house).

[0] https://www.epsilontheory.com/too-clever-by-half/



> Something is very wrong here if your house/apartment is getting cold and a CO2 meter near a window is not dropping. Author should take it outside and check to see a number <500ppm (probably closer to 420). Device could be broken or poorly calibrated. It happens.

She tried that: "I wondered, briefly, if my neighborhood just had terrible outdoor air quality—or if my device was broken. Within minutes of my bringing the meter outside, however, it displayed a chill 480."


Thanks, I read too fast.


The author did bring the sensor outside and got a reading of 480


Up to that point, I also assumed the meter was broken, but if it still shows reasonable values outside, I'm afraid it's the house that's broken.

Check the ventilation system to see if it's working properly. It may need to be cleaned or replaced. Maybe have some plants in your home. Maybe replace the gas stove with induction.

Or accept the higher CO2 levels. CO2 isn't personally dangerous like CO is. It's not ideal, but I think those warnings about loss of cognitive function are excessively alarmist.


One caveat is that the sensor is likely calibrated at least at atmospheric CO2 levels.

So many types of "broken" CO2 sensors might accurately work around 400ppm.


Oh, thats smart suggestion.


I'd guess the author has a window that doesn't open completely or doesn't have windows on opposite sides of the building. In my experience, it's much harder to get good airflow if the path looks like a U or an L, instead of a straight line.


Aren't you supposed to calibrate these by taking them outside and assuming that is 400ppm? If that's the case, you can't really use them to measure outside CO2.

I'm just learning about these, so I may not be understanding correctly.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: