Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

To me this sounds like an ad.


The original question was the perfect setup for an ad, more or less asking “have you ever done this before?”, “What should I be concerned about?”, and “How do I even start this?”. This response may seem ads-y, but it also answers the questions and provides interesting original thoughts (e.g., to start with a cost/benefit analysis). Even if it’s an ad, imo it’s a useful one


I saw a presentation on e-commerce back in the 90s, and this was an astroturfing strategy that was pitched even back then. Don't post a thread about your company, post a question on one account, and then on another account post that your company is the answer. Really it's a strategy that's been around for a lot longer than the internet.

Not saying that this is astroturfing, just that this format has been around forever.


Ya, if it’s two accounts controlled by the same person I agree it’s disingenuous. I think (hope?) that’s not the case here though


For the record, I have no connection to the original poster, and I’m not in the business of doing this anymore. I wanted to respond because I didn’t see any other threads pushing the OP to think about the basic economics and do some basic fermi estimations of the business case.


Yeah, I mean the easy to spot ones are usually the first ever post on a few days old account. Actually…


Yeah, ad like, but he is not wrong.

$5m is a solid number to ballpark any new initiative from scratch.


I get that but the suggestion would work even without dropping any company name.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: