Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is this seriously true?? (If so, where do they make their money?)


It's true that their profit margins can be vanishingly thin, but that doesn't mean they don't make money.

For some classes of items, they can sell at cost and still make money, because their operations are allegedly so good that they can turn over the inventory before their own payment to the supplier is due.

For example, say Amazon buys a book today and payment is due to the publisher in 30 days. They sell the book tomorrow at cost. Now they get to sit on the full price of the book for the rest of the month. In fact, take that money and buy another book, and sell it right away too. Keep that up, and you have a very big pool of money always sitting in your bank account. Money that can be profitably invested in other activities.

Why would a publisher give them 30 days to pay? Because they're Amazon. It's good to be big.


Net 30 is very common, even if you are not Amazon.


And lots of big companies will take 2X or 3X longer to pay you if they can get away with it.



They are optimizing for market share and innovation rather than profits. It's a world domination thing.

I think it's awesome. Imagine if Google had run a bunch of low-rent punch-the-monkey display ads early on. It would have killed them. Facebook vs MySpace is another good example of what happens when you focus on long-term value creation versus short-term profit taking.


Does that mean its a big bate and switch model? Get market share with cheap prices, destroy the competition then ramp up your prices.


With its low profit margin amazon leaves virtually no room for a small size competitor to dislodge them from their share of the market.

Say you want a bite of the tablet market dominated by apple, it's easy, make a somewhat decent tablet for cheap and there you have it.

If you want a bite of an amazon dominated market, well good luck with that, and while at it hope that amazon is not planning to get into the market you're in.

It seems their strategy relies on tiny margins, maybe with a different set or circumstances amazon would change their stance, but I don't think it's currently part of their plans to ramp up prices.


It depends on the product, a lot of cosmetics they seem to be selling at a decent margin and getting undercut by marketplace sellers.

If you are going up against the loss leader kindle though it is going to be a lot harder.


No, they're using low margins to keep market share, indefinitely.

There was an article on HN a couple of weeks ago precisely about this topic, decent read / informative.

Link: http://www.eugenewei.com/blog/2012/11/28/amazon-and-margins

HN Discussion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5112998


From Amazon's perspective, it's the only way to exist in the long term. If they keep costs and margins low, they don't give their competitors much breathing room to challenge them on price.


which has never worked in history. as soon as you raise prices, you lose market share...


I'm sure it's just a typo. But for the record, it's "bait and switch". A 'bate and switch model is something else entirely.


Lol, yes typo.


More likely the other way around. Destroy the competition and keep prices the same, but push costs down.


Volume, volume, volume!


If each item sells at a loss, more volume certainly doesn't help gain money.


Yes, it does. Maybe not from customers..




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: