Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I fully agree with you. The difference between 'retail' and 'bundle' discounts is a pretty good indicator software retail pricing is terribly wrong.

And then there is the fact that you could sell software online easily and you don't actually need a retail channel.

Direct-to-consumer is the only way that makes any sense at all. Why even have a physical goods channel for something that is outdated before it has left manufacturing ?

The other side of the coin is that now people are so used to being able to get that stuff for free that to reverse the trend away from wholesale copying is very difficult.

Plenty of people feel towards companies like microsoft the way they feel towards the taxman. You've already had me pay 6 times over to use this road, I refuse to pay you any longer. The profit margins of those companies don't help either.



Why even have a physical goods channel for something that is outdated before it has left manufacturing ?

Never underestimate the bandwidth of a tractor trailer of CDs.

(This is, relatedly, why there is a retail price for MMORPGs that companies would really rather give you for free. They don't give a farthing about the box money, they want to eliminate every barrier to you handing over your sweet sweet credit card details. However, if they don't charge for the box, then Best Buy won't stock them, and they'll lose accounts to their competitors who are on the shelves.)


One of the very legitimate uses of bittorrent is to solve this problem elegantly.

Sending out a gig of data even on EC2 (which is pretty expensive) costs about $0.10.

They can have my credit card details online via a secure http connection for the $1 they'll have to charge me to make up on the fees. Even beter, now they have that data instead of best buy.

After all, I highly doubt the privacy watchdogs would agree to bestbuy passing that information (especially the cc data) up the chain to the supplier.


After all, I highly doubt the privacy watchdogs would agree to bestbuy passing that information (especially the cc data) up the chain to the supplier.

Why not? Doesn't seem to be any different than buying and activating an iPhone at an Apple store. AT&T gets all of your billing information from Apple. If anything, it seems likely that Best Buy could do much tighter integration without anyone getting concerned.


Why don't they give the CDs to retailers for free, and let the retailers charge what they want for them?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: