Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Unfortunately, it is not true. In germany prostitution was legalized a few years ago and what mostly happened was a massive increase in it. The situation of prostitutes barely improved and human trafficking went up.

But you have to keep in mind that that is also the effect of only one country doing it. What would happen if the whole EU legalized prostitution is a different question.



This is a complete BS narrative made up by people campaigning for the criminalization of prostitution.

Prostitution has been legal in Germany since before WWII. That is, neither the offering nor the use of sexual services was a crime (pimping was and still is). What changed in 2000 is merely that prostitution lost its "unconscionable" status, meaning that it can in principle be the subject of enforceable contracts.


Well, here, in Algeria, prostitution isn't illegal. Many think it is, but the law doesn't incriminate the sex-worker, it incriminates the person who lives off of a sex worker or her handler if she has one. In fact, I think there are still establishments authorized by the State that have been up for more than 50 years or something, but those appear to be very drastic in their internal policy stuff.

A lot work for themselves. When I was in college, there were many girls who used it as a way to have some fun and some money (college is free, and a lot live in dorms that are also free)).

Also, it is not like in the U.S. (movies) in that you won't find sex-workers on the streets.

This stuff is pretty organized. Happens mostly in night-clubs or in dedicated places that are guarded with security, where you will be thrown out if you cause any problems or are too drunk to behave.

They generally have a compound with the club and the hotel inside, convenient if you plan to get wasted as you won't have to drive. Just a few yards and you're in bed.

These compounds offer a sort of "Security as a Service" and the girls "lease" the place (the client pays an additional fee). And many girls will just go from club to club, compound to compound. They have usual taxi-drivers who take them, etc.

The biggest hazard would be the fact they won't properly put a condom on a man. The usual way would be to put it while he's erect, and some need help, so the girls will perform fellatio on a limp phallus with a condom on and the phallus grows into the condom. They also use cheap condoms that are way too tight for anyone older than a 13 year old (crappy 52mm condoms).

Also, most of those who do anal don't have the proper lubes; so they'll have whatever makes it easy and it is often an oil based hair product, or something. They're not really aware of how latex reacts to that, etc.

And again, some clients are just idiots and want to have protection-free sex at all costs. The girls are reluctant to talk if they have a disease because there's a whole procedure and they'll lose their job, so they comply, infecting the person.

And as for Al Jazeera, is amusing that a Djihadist Channel doesn't even cover Qatar. They used to let nut-jobs go on for hours on their waves inviting people world-wide to kill Algerians because we're not "Arabs or Muslims". It's a channel that has glorified terrorists despite the atrocities they committed. Whether they're trying to make themselves a new virginity is another story.


a bit too informative post for my taste, but apparently you never know what you'll learn on HN :)


It may be 'nsfw', but this is a real issue, and how they handle it. It's also a great example of viral propagation, and how it applies to viruses via the sex trade (Rather than a social media phenomenon).


Seems to me that the real issue is pimping and how difficult it is to control.

http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/human-traffickin...

The women go there knowing that they will trade sex for money. What they do not know is how difficult and exploitative the work is.


The German system seems odd to say the least.

They have legalized the activity, but they seems to not want to get involved with the operational rules.

To borrow the drug comparison from further up, this would be like legalizing hard drugs but not putting down any ground rules for labeling or certification of content.

Consider alcohol. Most places it is legal to sell, but there are still regulations in place, and hopefully policed, detailing when and to whom it can be sold.

When people talk about legalizing drugs, they likely envision a similar system of regulations surrounding it.

Similarly regulations have to be put in place regarding working conditions etc for prostitutes as part of the legalization process.

Removing the sex aspect and the article reminds me of some of the shit the construction business has with exploiting foreign workers.

I recall reading about people living 6 to the room in what was supposed to be a single occupancy apartment etc.


> They have legalized the activity, but they seems to not want to get involved with the operational rules.

That's exactly the problem. Campaigning for tougher laws against sex trafficking is great voter bait, but actually enforcing the existing laws? That costs money!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: